COULDA, SHOULDA BUT DIDN’T

This post is an impossible dream. It could never happen. Its place is in the fiction section of your library. It is as far removed from reality as those nut-jobs who tell us Bill Gates has installed a locator chip in COVID vaccinations. This is my “Brian Tamaki” moment.

And so, if factual reports are your thing, try the Swimming New Zealand (SNZ) webpage. These days SNZ is a reliable source of swimming news. But anyway, here is my dream.

Just imagine the money Bruce Cotterill wasted on his catastrophic centralisation plan for SNZ. We know thatover 20 years it was about $25million. And what did we get? We certainly did not swim any faster. Before Cotterill got his hands on all that money swimmers like Hurring, Moss, Kingsman, Winter, van Wellie, Loader, Jeffs, Langrell and Simcic were winning medals at all sorts of world events. Cotterill spent most of the money on foreign coaches and administrators. A pile of our cash ended up in Australia, Spain, Singapore and the USA.

When finally, Tongue, Johns and Francis pulled the plug on the whole sad affair, there was nothing to show for the $25million – just a big empty hole. Even worse swimming administration and performance throughout New Zealand had been decimated. Good clubs and coaches lost their best swimmers lured to Auckland’s bright lights by SNZ. Whether SNZ knew the destruction of their policy we will never know. If they didn’t, they were morons. If they did, they were sporting terrorists.  

And so, we know what Cotterill did. He wasted money like a drunken sailor. But was there a better way? That question brings me to my dream. Here is what I would have done.

First, I would have abandoned the centralisation policy. That was never the way to build a strong sport. The only benefits of that policy were the boost it gave Cotterill’s ego and to several foreign bank accounts. A strong sport is built from the bottom up. What that means is establishing a strong infrastructure of clubs. Last weekend Hamilton Aquatics showed us what a well-run, strong club can achieve. That is where investment in swimming is needed. And that is how the Loaders, Jeffs, Simcics are found and nurtured to international success.

Second, I would have invested the $25million into an interest earning account. Instead of having nothing now, swimming would have the $25million earning interest of $1million each year.

Third, Sport New Zealand is still handing out about $1million a year to SNZ. This should not be fritted away as it is now but should be added to the $25million investment fund. The effect of this over five years is shown in the table below.

Year Opening Capital Sum Sport NZ Grant New Capital Sum Interest Earned Closing Capital Sum
2022 25,000,000 1,000,000 26,000,000 1,040,000 27,040,000
2023 27,040,000 1,000,000 28,040,000 1,121,600 29,161,600
2024 29,161,600 1,000,000 30,161,600 1,206,464 31,368,064
2025 31,368,064 1,000,000 32,368,064 1,294,722 33,662,786
2026 33,662,786 1,000,000 34,662,786 1,386,511 36,049,297

Fourth I would invite New Zealand’s 159 clubs to apply for funding from the reserves. Projects would have to be directly swimming related – for example, coaching wages, pool equipment and swimmer’s costs such as travel, food, rent, car expenses, uniforms and swimsuits. It’s called paying the worker’s wages. Administration and office costs would not qualify. Applications would be administered by trustees such as Gary Hurring, Lauren Boyle, Antony Moss and Sophia Batchelor. The amount available for distribution could never exceed the annual interest earned.

If that plan had happened in the twenty years Cotterill wasted $25million the sport would still have its capital asset. My bet is we would have also won a heap more international swimming medals. Why? Because the money would have been spent on those who win the medals and because clubs are run by people who know what they are doing.

Anyway, that’s my dream.  

0 responses. Leave a Reply

  1. Swimwatch

    Today

    Be the first to leave a comment!

Comments are closed.